Monday, August 12, 2024

Battle Report: In Strife and Conflict - Egyptians vs. Hittites in a prelude to Kadesh

 


Exciting times my friends.  This was a practice game in the run up to the big Battle of Kadesh game I want to host.  Therefore, the forces are not at maximum size yet as we get used to the rules.  We are having a "what-if" type of scenario where our two opponents forward forces have a meeting engagement prior to the big battle we know about at Kadesh.  

Forces

Egyptians
3 Light Chariots
- Composite Bows
- General
1 Professional Infantry
2 Auxiliary Infantry
- Composite Bows
4 Archers

Hittites
3 Heavy Chariots
- Javelins
- 1 General
1 Auxiliary Infantry
2 Levy Infantry
- Bows
2 Skirmishers

Mission: 
As the Egyptians are operating in the Levant against the Hittites, we made the Egyptians the Attackers and the Hittites the Defenders.  We then randomly determined the scenario using the method in the rules.  We were going to play a supply run.  The Hittites were moving vital supplies to Kadesh prior to the Egyptians getting there and laying siege to the city! 

The Hittites have three supply tokens they need to get off board in 8 turns and without breaking. 

Set-up:
Of course, we will be playing today on a 72MU by 48MU board with each MU equal to 1 inch.  

Using the core rulebook rules, we see a relatively open battlefield that is bisected by some hills.  The rest is fairly flat and open terrain, with one edge bordering a coast line. 

Egyptian Forces

The Egyptians from there left flank across are two archers, the Pharaoh, the Sherden Guard, some Auxiliary Infantry with bows, two light chariots, some Auxiliary infantry, and the last two archers. 

Hittite Forces

From the Hittite right to left is the Heavy Chariots, backed up by the infantry with the auxiliaries in the middle.  On the far flank on a hill is two units of skirmishers.  The Hittite commander has dispersed his supplies with the General, the spearmen infantry, and a unit of skirmishers.   


As usual, I won't be doing an exact play-by-play of the battle,  I will break it into the Maneuvering phase, Battle Phase, and End Game for brevity and simplicity.

Maneuver Phase

The two sides move-out.  The Egyptian chariots are on the opposite side of the board for the most part, as the Hittite forces lurch to their right flank.  The Egyptians are more evenly spread, but their Chariots seem to be more to their own right.  The Pharaoh is in the center.  One of the Hittites units with the supplies clambers up into a hill for extra defense.  

The two sides manage to do a bit of skirmishing early.  The Pharaoh gets a bead on the supply skirmishers on the hill and opens fire with their bows.  The cause a few troopers to fall.  In return, the escorting skirmishers charge into the Egyptian leader, he stands his ground and fights with them; eager for glory.  The fighting is a draw, reminding the Egyptian player that Light Chariots are best for shoot-n-scoot!  

Meanwhile, the Heavy Hittite chariots carrying supplies attack the Egyptian flank.  The heavy charge of the chariots easily routes the Egyptian archers they come in contact with!  The second Heavy Chariot peppers the other Egyptian Archers with ineffective missile fire. 

With the first Egyptian unit routed, the battle starts in earnest! 



Battle Phase:

The Egyptians start by firing a volley of arrows at a group of Heavy Chariots leading the Hittite advance.  They inflict minimal courage loss.  In response, the Hittites try to steal the initiative, and succeed!.  The supply carrying Chariots manage a flank charge on the archers and scatter them like seeds in the wind.  

The Egyptians try to regain the Initiative, but fail.  The Hittite Levy infantry fires at the Egyptian elites, who shrug off the attack. However, the Hittite skirmishers with the supplies manage to get behind a Levy Infantry screen.

The Royal Sherden Guards rush to the defense of the Pharaoh and easily smash their way through the Hittite Skirmishers and protect their paymaster.  They have proven their worth to the Pharaoh yet again! This allows the Pharaoh to regroup with his other light chariots, and start to move behind the Hittite line.  They pepper some Levy Infantry on a hill with archer fire, but for little effect. 


The battle has reached the half-way point, the Egyptians appear to be out of position, as the Hittites surge forward.  In an attempt to salvage a bad situation, the Egyptian Infantry on the hill use their Composite Bows on the Hittite King racing past below them, and cause minor injury on his entourage.  The Sherden guards charge the Levy infantry anchoring the Hittite rearguard, and attempt to scatter them off the hill.  They exchange courage loss, but the Levy is disordered from the Professional soldiers ferocious assault.  The Egyptian chariots desperately try to race around the flank and get behind the advancing Hittites, but it maybe too little too late.  

The Hittite King and his escorts throw Javelins back at the Egyptians on the hill, and with some luck manage to inflict minor injury on their attackers.  The Levy Infantry move up, blocking the enemy infantry from getting off the hill and after their supply bearers.  

The Hittite king swings around the hills, and charges into the Egyptian archers.  They try to Evade, but the Hittite King has too much momentum.  He crashes into them, but fails to scatter them.  The remaining Chariot and Infantry fire arrows and throw Javelins into the infantry on the hill, but fail to cause any damage.  The Hittite Levy infantry manages to throw the Sherden guard off the hill with few casualties, they manage to refrain from following up.  The supplies with the Hittite Heavy Chariot escape the board successfully.  

The Egyptian Infantry on the hill charges down to attack the Hittite Levy Infantry blocking their way.  They manage to push the Hittites back in the combat.  The Pharaoh and his chariot guard see the Hittite troops breaking away from them, can they catch them in time?  

End Phase

The Hittite Skirmishers with the supplies dash for safety.  The Egyptians manage to steal the initiative to try and chase down the enemy.  The Egyptian Light Chariots manage to catch-up to the fleeing Skirmishers, and shoot down the fleeing soldiers with ease!   However, the Hittite spearmen are made of tougher stuff, and shrug it off.  


The Egyptian Auxiliary Infantry charges at a Heavy Chariot, but they manage to deftly evade the attack.  As they race past, they pepper the impudent Egyptians with Javelins causing minimal damage.  The Disordered Hittite Levy Infantry on the hill, pulls itself together long enough to charge down into the flank of the infantry battle, but fail to sway the fight.  The Hittite King again fails to scatter the Egyptian archers.  

Going into turn 7 of 8, the Egyptians are closing in on their prey.  The Hittites spend all their King's Decree to get their last unit off the board and for a win.  However, they make it to the board edge.  The Egyptians have 1 last chance to stop them from escaping.  The Egyptians let them play out the rest of their turn, with the Hittites scattering an archer unit, and the Levy Infantry pushing the Egyptians back!  However, the Hittite infantry is on the brink of routing.  

An Egyptian Light Chariot desperately charges forward at full speed to tie-up the supply unit, but fail to get there and are disordered by the effort!  The follow-up Light Chariots rush forward and fire arrows, but fail to stop the Hittite troops.    


The Final turn, the Hittites spend all their King's Decree.  The Egyptians do too.  This forces a roll-off, which the Hittites win.  They activate their Infantry unit with the supplies and flee the board, ending the game.  

Conclusion:

A Hittite victory as they get 2 out of 3 supply tokens off the board edge.  It went down to the last die roll of the game, which is usually a sign of a well-fought battle!  

Two mistakes occurred during this game.  First, I deployed 1 Egyptian archer unit too many in deployment.  Second, we rolled up the Bad Water complication and then completely forget to use it during the game!  Woops. 

Here are some additional final thoughts.  First, heavy chariots are deadly!  They smashed through whole units in a single turn.  Granted, they were archer units, but still pretty impressive.  Second, Light Chariots are great at flitting about and shooting stuff like crazy.  They also allow for quick re-deployment and response.  They were a ton of fun to control!  Being on terrain helps a lot to defend against missiles and assaults, dug in infantry is hard to move.  The changes to infantry movement, charging distances, missile ranges, etc. all give this a very different feel than my Greek/Roman games.  There is a lot more movement and less line-up and bash!  I like it!  

Hopefully, this gives you a good feel for the game.  Next up, I am going to do a dry run of Kadesh, and then figure out when I am going to put on that community game with it!  You can pick-up these rules now on my Blood and Spectacles page on the Wargame Vault now.  

Until next time! 


Become a Patron and get access to all the cool stuff, a peak behind the curtain of Blood and Spectacles, and early-access to playtest games!  


You can follow Blood and Spectacles Facebook page or Instagram for more fun! 

Check out the latest publications and contact me at our Blood and Spectacles website

Or purchase all out games at the Blood and Spectacles Publishing Wargames Vault Page!                  

        

Monday, August 5, 2024

Random: 2024 Mid-Point, not to be confused with Midway

 


Dang.  Would you look at the time.  Like sands through the hourglass, these are the days of our lives.

Long time readers will recall that I put together some guideline goals at the beginning of the year to help shape what I am working on.  This year was no exception.  Since July is over, it seems like now is a good time to pause and take stock of the situation.  How am I doing with those goals?  Have I fallen off the track or am I on target.... to mix my metaphors!      

Normally, I break my goals down into the following areas:
  • Purchases
  • Painting/Modelling
  • Gaming
  • Writing
  • Miscellaneous Hobby Stuff
So, let's get this train in the air!  

Purchases
None of this section would be possible without the generous financial support of readers like you! 

Every time you purchase one of my books from Osprey, my Wargame Vault page, my Drive-Thru RPG page, and follow my Patreon you are helping to fund the continued existence of Blood and Spectacles Publishing.  The money I earn from these areas I put back into content on the blog, content on Social Media, and new products for you!  Any money I earn goes back into the business of wargaming and role-playing.  Thank you!  I could not do it without you!

With that said, it is always hard to decide how I intend to use these investments into purchases for the year.  Going into this year, I had a few goals lined out for what I should purchase to help generate content.  Looking at my goals, I have been following my intentions pretty closely.  
  • I have stayed caught up with the Osprey Wargaming Series and posted reviews.  Those titles were With Hot Lead and Cold Steel and When Nightmares Come.  There was some delay due to local availability, but I think that is sorted for now.  
  • I have purchased at least one new set of rules that were not Osprey and posted a review.  In this case, I picked up Modiphius' 5 Parsecs from Home which is a Sci-fi, model-vs-model, solo-game 
  • I picked up a couple of Kill Teams.  They were the Hand of the Archon, Sisters of Battle, and a Blooded Chaos Guard team.  Two of them were from my local FLGS.  
  • I also picked up a force of Anglo-Saxons from Victrix for use with my Fury of the Northman rules.  I wanted to expand my forces for some of my own games for Batreps and demo games. When Victrix sent me a 20% code, I couldn't resist. Expect to see my journey with these little soldiers on the blog. 
  • I also picked up the Kill Team starter set. 
  • I also picked up a single Heroquest expansion and provided a review for it; Against the Ogre Hordes  
Not a bad start, the only thing I still have to deliver on is to pick-up a new set of RPG rules.  I have been really torn on what to purchase.  I have waivered between Vampire: The Masquerade, Traveller, Tomorrow City, Cyberpunk: Red, Candela Obscura and Masks: The New Generation.  I am also looking at what my RPG group might want to play, and that is not helping me decide since they seem pretty set on D20 5E-alikes and I DO NOT WANT THAT! I want to be exposed to something new.  

My wife did express some interest in the My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic RPG but I am all ready familiar with the Essence 20 system, so I have been reluctant to act.  She claimed she would be willing to GM the game too, which would be a big change for her!  Familiarity with the system has also made me reluctant to get some other RPGs if they are just derivatives of games I have all ready played or own.   

I am open to some RPG suggestions in the comments. 





Painting/Modelling
Wow, I have been pretty productive on this front for the year.  I finished off a lot of projects in that time period!  I have ~175 minis painted so far!  Most of that was in the late winter and early spring.  Summer slowed me down a bit due to other activities and hot weather that wasn't great for painting.  My house does not have A/C, because back when my homestead was built that was not needed in this region.   
  • Painted my 6mm Hittite forces and the city of Kadesh for In Strife and Conflict
  • The Kill Team starter set and three other Kill Teams all painted up!     
  • Finished the Heroquest core set which includes models, furniture, and doorways
  • Painted some assorted miniatures as palette cleansers for various side projects
The Hittites March to War! 


Fully painted Heroquest Core Set in Action!

  
Kill Team Starter Set on the tabletop! 

Kind of impressed with my output so far! 

Gaming
I think I am about on track with two games a month.  I started really strong in late Winter, but have fallen off the wagon a bit.  Not sure why, but gaming has not been high on my priority list lately.  Here are some highlights: 

  • Wrapped up the Siege Perilous campaign with the True Crit Gaming Guild.  I played for both Imperial and Chaos depending on who else was there.  A resounding victory for Chaos in the campaign.  
  • Managed to play a test game for In Strife and Conflict
  • Played a few games of Hostile Space with my kitbashed/converted Mecha toys
  • Unexpectedly got to play a few games of Shadows of Brimstone
  • A weekly RPG session that is mostly D&D 5E so far this year. 
In Strife and Conflict 

Fury of the Northman

Engagement in Hostile Space

Shadows of Brimstone


D&D 5E from my weekly RPG session

Rules Writing
When 2024 started, I didn't think I would have much to finish for the year.  Mostly, I was focusing on getting In Strife and Conflict over the finish line and into circulation.  I managed that, but I also had a few other wins for the first half of the year!  

  • Hostile Space is on the Wargame Vault.  This is a game of anime inspired, space mecha combat.  I am also working on an RPG version of this game for release sometime later. 
  • Into the Snake Pit is on Drive Thru RPG.  This is a free module for the G.I. Joe: Role-playing Game that I wrote.  I want to play the game, so I wrote a module for my group and made it available to everyone. 
  • No Dice is on Drive Thru RPG.  This is a diceless role-playing game that uses keyword chains to overcome challenges.  Perfect for Forum or text-based games but also works just fine in-person too.  
  • Insanity at Snowden Manor is a module for Flashlight: Tales of Terror and both are on Drive Thru RPG.  This is a module I have played a couple of times and with good results overall. 
  • In Strife and Conflict  is freshly available on our Wargame Vault page.  This was a chariot wars game based on Assyrian history.  It covers a broad period of time from early Bronze Age to early Iron Age.  This one was 5+ years in the making. 





Miscellaneous Stuff
This stuff has also been moving forward.  However, there is one thing that has kind of stalled out.  I wanted to run a Battle of Kadesh demo game at my FLGS and local libraries, but I have not really followed through on this one.  My schedule has been crazy, and I am not 100% sure how to go about running a "Learning Experience" style game where the goal is educational as well as fun!  

I have also finally been able to get my Website up-to-date with all my release activity.  I have improved my Social Media game with different and better content.  I have also been able to add more "Value-add" content on my Patreon.  All good steps. 

Other News
So, that was a lot of stuff done.  However, it has not been all roses and good news here at the Farrington Homestead.  This has been a tough spring.  Some of you may know, that I have a small Friends Not Food Homestead that I operate.  This has a wide variety of animals from goats, pigs, chickens, cats, dogs, and more.  This spring was a bit of a tough one for us here at the Homestead.  

Our long time companion and wargaming friend Tia the black cat left us.  She was about 14 years old, and is sorely missed.  She was my lap cat and long time friend.  We had moved around together a few times and she had often helped me write, play and paint a lot of the projects you see on the blog.  She is survived by her sister Oreo who is also a sometimes contributor on the blog and social media page.  


In addition, we lost three of our six chickens.  Two had suffered a tough winter and never fully recovered.  The third sickened and died over the hot, hot summer.  They were all about 4 years old as we got them all at the same time..  We lost Kruschev, a Red Star Pullet, Vin Diesel a Buff Orpington, and Red, a Rhode Island Red.  They were all friendly and talkative chickens that were very curious.  I miss them very much as they were my yardwork companions.
Kruschev

Red
Vin Diesel

Lastly, we lost two little buddies in the form of Salt and Pepper.  These were a couple of rescue rats that were sisters and both about 4 years old.  They were playful little ladies who loved to go inverted in their cages.  They were not much for leaving their home, not even for cuddles; but were always eager to see you stop by and visit.  

Salt and Pepper respectively

 Of course, some good stuff happened too!  My wife graduated college with an AA degree, and is continuing with her Bachelors.  My kid started college as well.  Our family managed to continue our charitable work of giving free clothes away and helping folks with Mental Health in our community too.  I am also a member of the Beneficent and Protective Order of the Elks.  We continue to meet lots of people in the gaming hobby and the local community, and look to make the rest of this year just as productive about trying to make our rural community a better place for all.  

Until next time!


Become a Patron and get access to all the cool stuff, a peak behind the curtain of Blood and Spectacles, and early-access to playtest games!  


You can follow Blood and Spectacles Facebook page or Instagram for more fun! 

Check out the latest publications and contact me at our Blood and Spectacles website

Or purchase all out games at the Blood and Spectacles Publishing Wargames Vault Page!    

       



    

Monday, July 29, 2024

Wargame Design: In Strife and Conflict

 


This game has been a long time in the making.  Those of you who are my Patrons on Patreon have had access to these rules for a year or so.  With their help I have been able to make some adjustments to the game to finalize these rules.  There help focused on finish off these rules.  As thanks, they got access to the finished product months prior to everyone else.  In addition, the Patrons have also had access to the RPG rules of Space Mecha Theatre, a G.I. Joe RPG module, as well as various other work in progress games.  Some games are at the earliest stages, while others are in late stage post-production.   

For the In Strife and Conflict PDF, I needed to paint a couple of armies as part of post-production.  Then, once the two forces were painted I needed to take some photos of them in action.  I am not a photographer and many people would argue I am not much of a painter either.  However, I took a lot of photos and not all of them made it into the rules PDF.  However, I didn't want them to to go to waste.  Therefore, I decided to post them on the Blog as a bit of a photo dump.  

I also decided to use this time to talk about some of the Design Goals.  This game had the following Design Goals when I built them: 


Natives block the Pass

The rules themselves use the Heirs of Empire system as a base.  They were written initially about 5 years ago?  It took that long to prioritize them and complete the post-production.  In that time, I got a lot of great feedback about how to do supporting, the turn sequence, movement speeds, and other points.  I was able to incorporate a lot of those ideas into the core rules themselves.  

Chariots rush forward to clash

As usual, I want all my games to be base and model agnostic.  These ones are no exception.  I used 60 x 60mm bases, but I realize that the base size I chose is not a "universal" choice.  Most people like 40mm frontages.  However, frontage is not really important in this game as long as both sides are roughly based the same.  However, there is some discussion about using multi-based units or single based units.  Therefore, you can really play with 2mm-54mm scale if the players wish.  This is a Unit-vs-Unit game.  

If you are familiar with Wars of the Republic or Men of Bronze you know that I worked to emphasize close combat.  However, in these rules I changed up the base mechanics to emphasize the mobility of chariots and to enhance the role of firepower.  Close combat will still have a role, but archery is much more powerful in these rules than my other ancient rules.  In addition, integrated archery is a key part for a number of core units.  


One of the interesting things about Chariot warfare in the Bronze Age and Early Iron Age is that no one really knows exactly how it worked.  In addition, different nations may have used their Chariot forces in different ways.  For example, it was commonly believed that the Egyptians used their Chariots as a mobile firepower platform.  Assyrians used their Chariots as a mobile shock force, and even used carts to move infantry around as "battle taxis".  Hittites had different types of chariots for different battlefield roles, but what were those roles?  Did they charge with spears?  Did they just get into an advantageous position and dismount?  It is not clear at all how large forces of Chariots were managed or coordinated on the battlefield.  Did they operate in large formations all together?  Did they operate on a tactical scale with squadrons operating alone?  Did they act as individual units?  What exactly was a "Chariot Runner"?  How fast were chariots compared to guys on foot?  How did you use them in a siege?  There are a lot of unanswered questions about Chariot Warfare, so a strong Point-of-View was needed for these rules.               

Therefore, much of how I decided the game would play was based on some assumptions I made about Chariot Warfare.  For fast-paced games, I chose to lean into the idea that Chariots were a mobility element of the army that could go faster and further than foot units.  Is this true?  No one is sure! However, for the purposes of "This Game" I wanted Chariots to be able to zip around quickly, shoot at other units, and hit harder than the equivalent foot units.  I wanted the Chariots to be the logical "core" of a force because they had benefits that other units could not bring.  We don't exactly know how the Ancients used Chariots but we do know they spent a lot of time, effort, and resources to have chariot forces.  Therefore, they must have been a key factor on the battlefield for a reason so I wanted that to be reflected in the game.  

Laying Siege to a city-state

 Like most of my games, I want players to be engaged at all times.  The best way I have found to do that was to make a fluid Initiative system based on using Command Points combined with triggering Special Rules for units with those points.  This is a standard conceit in my Men of Bronze- adjacent games.  In this game, I theme it around a resource called King's Decree.  The King was often the center of the army, and many of our surviving accounts focus on the role of the King/Pharaoh of the force.  It thematically made sense to tie Command Points to the King in this game.    

The game is designed to be played as a Unit-vs-Unit game.  Therefore, the exact number of models is not spelled out.  It depends on what the players decide a "Unit" is composed of and I leave it intentionally vague in the rules.  However, actions happen at a unit basis.  A Unit could be a single based model, a handful of single based units, or a few multi-based units.  It doesn't matter.  However, maneuvers and interactions happen at the unit-vs-unit level.  Special Rules are triggered at the unit level. 

Typically, the game plays with 4+ units per side.  I haven't really found a "top" to the number of units as the game can play pretty fast.  However, I think the "sweet spot" is 4-12 per side to play a game in about 1-2 hours of gameplay.  There is not really a "top" I have found yet as the rules are easy enough for larger games too.  However, unlike Heirs of Empire this is not designed for "Wings" of the army.  However, there is no reason you could not break it into multiple commands and have multiple players per side.  My personal belief is that armies in this period were not that large, despite what some scholars will claim about the size of the armies at battles like Kadesh.  Therefore, a "wings" system did not seem relevant for this game system, but wargamers being wargamers we always want more toys! 

A typical force size

Since this is a unit-vs-unit game, a big difference I make in these rules is that I assume all units are in the best formation for them.  Therefore, if you want to be in a different formation it takes the use of King's Decree to move them into a different formation.  This is similar to how I structured it in Heirs to Empire.  Therefore, most units have some turning and direction restrictions.  Not all units can go into a more maneuverable formation, and there is a cost to being in those looser formations.  

Notably, I did not include the "Melee Phase" in this game.  Instead, I opted to have all melee occur at the time of impact during an activation. I find that this approach makes controlling the Initiative much more impactful during the game.  It does lead to some situations with how "support" works and units charging in after a melee has started.  The rules are much clearer on these points thanks to feedback from my previous games that use this model. 

Two other things I did for this set of rules.  First, I formatted it to no longer use two columns per page.  Some of my early work did this, and I received feedback that it was harder to use as a PDF with that formatting.  Therefore, I went with single pages at a time which should be easier for PDF viewing.  Second, I wised up and finally added a QRS into the document!  That should be a handy resource to print out when you play your first few games.  

Chariots attack while the infantry forms a solid defensive base

Final Thoughts

If you are familiar with my Ancient games, you will see a lot of familiar mechanics and ideas in this game.  The main challenge of this rulebook was to match the core themes of Chariot Warfare with appropriate mechanics to try and catch the proper Point-of-View for the style of warfare within the rules framework I use for Ancient games.  That meant emphasizing the mobility and potential power of the chariots, and using infantry as a base to operate for support, firepower, and holding ground.  I also improved missile firepower compared to my Greek/Roman focused games. 

Overall, I am really happy with how the game plays.   This was a modification and not a revolution of the core system.  If you have liked my other Ancients games, you will like this.  If you have not liked them you will not like this one.  

Let me know if you have any questions.  Until next time. 


Become a Patron and get access to all the cool stuff, a peak behind the curtain of Blood and Spectacles, and early-access to playtest games!  


You can follow Blood and Spectacles Facebook page or Instagram for more fun! 

Check out the latest publications and contact me at our Blood and Spectacles website

Or purchase all out games at the Blood and Spectacles Publishing Wargames Vault Page!         


  

      



    

    


   

 

Monday, July 22, 2024

Wargame Design Discussion: Game Masters in Wargames

 


Game Masters you say?  Is this supposed to be about Wargame Design or RPG Design?  Game Masters are a Role-playing Game thing.  It is one of their defining traits!  

Yeah..... about that.  

Game Masters (Referees, Umpires, Control) have been part of wargaming since the very beginning.  I am not an expert on the history of Wargaming, but some of the earliest examples were Kriegspiel.  This was a wargame used by the Prussian General Staff to help train officers in the conduct of warfare after the Napoleonic Wars.  It relied heavily on other Officers to act as referees to interpret and apply orders in the game.  

This tradition stayed with wargames, and is still used in many Politico-Military wargames run today.  In 2024, the US Coast Guard ran a wargame to help prepare participants to think about US Coast Guard doctrine for the next 30 years, and it was run by a Game Master.  The same is true of many of the Wargames regarding the Taiwan Strait or the (in)famous Millennial Challenge wargame.

Readers probably also recall that Role-Playing games themselves were just a down-scaled wargame where the players handled 1-character at a time rather than units of troops.  RPGs are well-known for using Game Masters.  This was a practice taken from the roots in wargaming from early versions like Chainmail.   

In the Hobby, Miniature Wargaming market the Game Master was also a common component in the mid to late 70s and 80s.  Many of us got our start in wargaming with Warhammer: Rogue Trader.  This game heavily features a Game Master for scenario design, balancing forces, deployment, and mission creation.  They also ran NPCs, surprise encounters, and made rules interpretations and decisions during the game.  This tradition continues in Games Workshop's Inquisitor as well.        

My venerable copy of Rogue Trader


What Game Masters Bring to the Table
There was a reason that games were using Game Masters to begin with?  What were these additional folks bringing to the table?  Why were they included in the first place?  

1. Teach the game
70% of learning is doing, and a Game Master is a great way to get players stuck in and learning the game from the first moment they pick up a miniature.  The player doesn't need to know the rules backwards and forwards, they can rely on the received knowledge of the Game Master for direction on operations and focus on the fun aspects of the game.  Meanwhile, they learn as they go. 

2. Adjudicate rules disputes and make rulings
There is no system in the world that doesn't have edge cases and opportunities to break.  The Game Master can paper over these situations by making rulings.  They can also short circuit rules arguments between players by being the "final word" on how to play a situation in the moment.  

3. Play NPCs
Some games benefit from interaction with Non-Player Characters in the game.  These could be Aides-de-camp and their opinions on how things are going, captured enemy scouts, or your own officers reporting up the chain of command.  The Game Master can play these non-player characters in a game for various effects. 

4. Allow Fog-of-War
The Game Master can interpret what any player sees, and provide mis-information, confusion, or other details to a player.  This could be pre-game, during deployment, or even during gameplay.  This information allows the game to have a higher degree of uncertainty and risk than games without Game Masters.  The GM can also monitor hidden deployments, flank marches, reserves, etc.  

5. Add Complications
The Game Master can add a variety of complications that are unknown or hidden from all players, some player, or just a single player.  These complications then force players to make decisions based on limited or imprecise knowledge.   

6. Determine Outcomes of Decisions
Finally, a Game Master can determine consequences or outcomes of decisions.  If a player decides to use a narrow road, does it slow their movement?  Does it cause disorder?  The Outcomes do not have to be set or scripted by the rules, they could be improvised by the GM or just hidden from the players.  This adds more Fog-of-War, Friction, and complications when things do not always go to a calculation.  

7. Forge the Narrative
Game Masters can help in this process by making scenes, outcomes, or new developments very cinematic or narrative in nature.  They can take the random occurrences on the battlefield and help the players shape them into a larger defining narrative of the game.  

8. Be Fun
A Game Master adds additional social engagement to the entire game experience.  They can crack wise, console bad luck, and cheer along with you.  They can be a social lubricant to help the game play be smooth and fun as now it is a game of three people instead of just two. 

In many, modern, hobby-based miniature wargames new mechanics have been created to try to replicate these various aspects of what a Game Master used to do.  However, it is open for debate if these mechanics are an improvement on the human role of Game Master.  


GMs Go Home!
Despite this track record and history, modern, hobby focused miniature wargames have moved away from the Game Master model.  It is often seen as an archaic design choice.  Instead, they have been replaced by the rules themselves for dictating and arbitrating what is supposed to happen in a game, and what effects are seen on the tabletop.  Why?  

I have a couple of theories on the move away from Game Masters: 

1. The primacy of rules
The gentlemanly rules writing style has fallen out-of-favor with many modern players.  In the old days, rules could be written a bit looser, as the GM or the players themselves were assumed to be able to work-out the details as fellow gentleman.  However, players have demanded that rule sets "tighten up" in order to avoid ambiguity and remove the social decision making aspect out of the hobby.  The Rules are suppose to be the final arbiter of what should happen in a game, rather than any other source.  

2. The rise of pick-up culture
With the rise of Pick-up Culture in gaming, the primacy of rules is critical.  Two random strangers enter a neutral, third space and play a game with no other commonalities between them.  The Rules themselves are to create that bridge between these two strangers.  If the rules do not cover it, these two strangers are at an impasse.  

As this type of gaming became more common in miniature wargaming circles, the rules themselves had to reflect these changes.  No more could writers rely on a group of like-minded buddies around a table.  They had to make sure that the rules could work if two complete strangers met up in a game store, club, pub, or the street to play a wargame. 

The wargame scene was atomizing into smaller and smaller components. 

3. I need 3 people to play this game now!   
As this atomization occurred, wargamers became much more "singular".  They were expected to meet-up and play a game.  Trying to organize three players to get in a game was much more difficult, therefore games had to cater to two player at most.  Games designed for more than two players fell out of favor commercially in the industry because it was a limiting factor to getting a game.  The Game Master became a liability to getting a game in. 

4. Competitive Gaming
Of course, many of these factors were also linked to the rise of the competitive scene in wargame, as games moved away from being a form or learning/recreation and into more of an arena of skill/sport over time.  Here again, the Game Master was a liability as the role could inject uncertainty into outcomes that were anathema to the Competitive ideology.  Certainty, known outcomes, and set statistical probabilities were essential for a competitive scene to function between two random strangers. 

Even a casual reader can see how these factors have all intermingled and grown in such a way, that the Game Master became a liability to the growth of the miniature wargaming hobby rather than a benefit.

There are probably more reasons or theories, but those are the ones I am going to postulate for today.  Feel free to add your thoughts or other ideas about why the GM has become less common in wargaming in the comments below.  I would appreciate it.  

A Game with a Game Master

Why Design with a Game Master in Mind? 
Based on why Game Master went away, I find it highly unlikely that they will return in a big-way to mainstream miniature wargaming.  The reasons they went away are still too prevalent in the market.  In fact, the market has potentially atomized even further with the rise in demand and popularity of solo-play games over the last few years.  I only see this trend accelerating as Society as a whole becomes more solitary for a variety of cultural and sociological reasons that are way beyond the scope of this little musing.  

So, if this is not the future but the past of Wargaming, then why am I even talking about it?  Well, because a lot of non-miniature, non-hobby wargames still make extensive use of the Game Master.  Therefore, the role still has a fundamental value that sometimes can only be met as a human.  Nothing yet can improve and react to a changing experience better than a Human Game Master can. 

With that in mind, a Game Master can be really important to your game and something to consider if you plan on having some of the following elements feature heavily in your game: 

1. A one-shot club or Con game
In this type of environment, the Game Master can teach the players as the game is ongoing.  The players themselves probably do not have much time or interest in learning all the nuances of a complex rule system.  They want to get in, get a feel for the game, and play.  A Game Master can help smooth over a lot of the bumps in this process by giving options, knowing the rules so players do not have to, and explaining rules only when they become relevant to the game at the moment.  

2. A high-level of role-play
If your game expects a high-level of RPG-Lite in the function of the game, then an impartial Game Master can help determine suitable outcomes and results during the game, especially when players inevitably go off-script and do something that the game itself does not explicitly cover.  

3. Fog-of-War/Hidden Actions
The Game Master can be an impartial observer and monitor for where actual units are, where they are not, and outcomes of actions well-beyond the scope of the 4Ms.  With a GM, things like Double-Blind deployment, hidden movement and set-up, unexpected battlefield conditions, etc, can all play a role in your game.  

4. Evolving Complications/Friction
If you game has escalating friction or levels of unexpected complications, a Game Master is useful to make decisions on when these situations apply, and how they apply to the game.  The intention is to make the player make tough decisions and manage the Friction.  Game Masters can apply these quicker and easier than mechanics like charts and If/Then rules and can do so only with guidelines as opposed to mechanical systems.  

5. High Degree of the Unknown
Games with a lot of Unknown elements like guerrilla ambushes, mine fields, unexploded ordinance, and other 3rd party or ambush type factors can benefit greatly from a GM to decide when and how they come into play.  The GM can also adjudicate when players themselves try to move beyond the scope of the rules and into "unknown" territory as well.  

All of these situations are ideal for a Game Mastered game.         




Final Thoughts
Wargames have a long tradition of using Game Masters to help run a smooth game for the players, and this tradition is still alive and well.  However, the hobby, miniature wargame market has moved away from this as a feature for a variety of reasons, often related to the atomization of the hobby into smaller and smaller units of participation.  Despite this move away from a Game Master, there are times and places when a Game Master can still be an important and relevant part of a wargame's design.  

Like most mechanics, a Game Master can be a useful tool that a designer should consider and keep in their tool box.  The designer's job is to make sure they can apply the right tool, at the right time, to get the outcome they want for the game.  It is important to know how and why a Game Master can be useful.  

Until next time! 


Become a Patron and get access to all the cool stuff, a peak behind the curtain of Blood and Spectacles, and early-access to playtest games!  


You can follow Blood and Spectacles Facebook page or Instagram for more fun! 

Check out the latest publications and contact me at our Blood and Spectacles website

Or purchase all out games at the Blood and Spectacles Publishing Wargames Vault Page!